| 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Application and method  | 
          
             Estimated installed cost  | 
          
             Estimated installed cost  | 
          
               | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             S A Rand  | 
          
             US Dollars  |  
          
             unit  | 
 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             Velocities < 6 m / sec   | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Hyson Cells  | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             a  | 
          
             10 to 20 MPa concrete fill with Manning between 0.012 
            and 0.014  | 
          
             R35  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             R45  | 
          
             $6  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             $8  | 
          
             / m²  | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             b  | 
          
             No-fines concrete fill with vegetation  | 
          
             R25  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             R45  | 
          
             $4  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             $8  | 
          
             / m²  | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Cast concrete panels  | 
          
             R45  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             R65  | 
          
             $8  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             $11  | 
          
             / m²  | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Needs shuttering. Alternate slabs poured. Thickness 
            can vary.  | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Concrete block lining placed on non woven 
            geotextile  | 
          
             R65  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             R85  | 
          
             $11  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             $14  | 
          
             / m²  | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Concrete block lining is connected with wires. Prone 
            to rust.  | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Concrete with grass blocks placed on 
            geotextile  | 
          
             R65  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             R85  | 
          
             $11  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             $14  | 
          
             / m²  | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Reno mattress / gabion placed on 
          geotextile  | 
          
             R125  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             R250  | 
          
             $21  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             $42  | 
          
             / m²  | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Needs selected stone. Labour intensive.  | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Thick-wall geocells  | 
          
             R45  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             R85  | 
          
             $8  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             $14  | 
          
             / m²  | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Rigidity means limited ability to mould to contours 
            and can allow water to flow underneath the cell mat.  | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             Velocities 6 m / sec to 10 m / sec  | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Hyson Cells  | 
          
             R35  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             R55  | 
          
             $6  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             $9  | 
          
             / m²  | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Fill is 20 MPa to 30 MPa concrete. Manning of 0.012 - 
            0.014.  | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Soft-wall cells act as formwork to cast a 3D 
            interlocking "cell slab". The formwork is sacrificial and acts as 
            jointing. Flexible on poor founding materials such as clay. 
              | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Releases hydrostatic pressures caused by varying water 
            tables yet as waterproof as conventional concrete canals. 
            | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Cast concrete panels  | 
          
             R110  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             R150  | 
          
             $18  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             $25  | 
          
             / m²  | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Needs jointing for this velocity. Uses shuttering. 
            Compaction and curing important.  | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             Velocities 10 m / sec to 20 m/sec  | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Hyson Cells  | 
          
             R45  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             R65  | 
          
             $8  | 
          
             to  | 
          
             $11  | 
          
             / m²  | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Fill is 30 MPa to 40 MPa concrete. Manning of 
            0.012-0.013.  | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Parabolic cross-section preferred. Advise use of 200 
            mm deep cut-off beams across the channel under the concrete liner up 
            to 1  5 metres of channel length. Settlement pond to be used at 
            end of fall. No steps.  | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Reinforced concrete panels  | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
          
             | 
        
          | 
             | 
          
             | 
          
             Usually involves stepping to break the velocity. 
            Rubber jointing needed. Also uses cut-off beams and settlement 
            ponds.  |